Nick’s Fishmarket Maui Menu Guide: What to Expect & Must-Try Dishes

If you’re searching for a top-tier dining experience in Wailea-Makena, the Nick’s Fishmarket Maui menu offers an unforgettable blend of fresh seafood, premium steaks, and island-inspired cuisine. Located in the luxurious Fairmont Kea Lani resort, Nick’s Fishmarket is not just a restaurant—it’s a Maui dining destination for families, couples, and wine enthusiasts alike.

Whether you’re a returning guest or planning your first visit, this guide breaks down what to expect from the Nick’s Fish Market menu, including standout selections, Happy Hour details, extras like their wine list and keiki menu, and what diners are saying about their experiences.

🌺 What to Expect on the Nick’s Fishmarket Maui Menu

Nick’s Fishmarket blends the flavors of Hawaii with Mediterranean influences to create a refined yet approachable menu. Guests can enjoy a diverse selection of seafood, steaks, and vegetarian options—all crafted with locally sourced ingredients.

🍤 Appetizers to Start the Night Right

The appetizer selections on the Nick’s Fishmarket Maui menu are bold and inventive. Whether you’re sharing with the table or starting your meal off solo, each dish is crafted to impress.

Must-Try Picks:

• B&B Ahi – Seared rare and blackened, paired with sake-mustard beurre blanc and tropical fruit relish.
• Charred Octopus – Mediterranean preparation with gnocchi, roasted olives, and feta.
• Seafood Chowder – A hearty bowl filled with Hawaiian fish, lump crab, bacon, and Yukon gold potatoes.

⭐ “BLOWN away with our experience… Devin, our server, was 5 star. Obsessed with oysters and Maui Wowie Salad. I’d eat here every night if I could.”
— Kim Schaper, Google Review

🥗 Fresh Island-Inspired Salads

Nick’s offers unique, flavorful salads that are more than just a side dish—they’re a culinary experience.

Must-Try Pick:

• Greek Maui Wowie Salad – Tiger prawns, avocado, romaine, and Maui onions dressed with a caper vinaigrette.

🌟 “From the moment we arrived, the experience at Nick’s Fishmarket was nothing short of exceptional… the oysters were some of the best we’ve ever had—so fresh, and perfectly chilled.”
— Nanea, OpenTable Review

🐟 Signature Entrees

From fresh local catches to expertly grilled steaks, the Nick’s Fish Market menu Maui offers an impressive range of entrees for every palate.

Must-Try Picks:

• Potato Scaled Mahi Mahi – Topped with beurre rouge, served with mashed potatoes and asparagus.
• Ginger-Soy Marinated Ahi – Ahi tuna with wasabi whipped potatoes and lemongrass au jus.
• 14 oz Rib Eye Steak – Served with loaded mashed potatoes and grilled asparagus.
• Avocado “Mujadra” – A delicious plant-based option with black Thai rice and warm mango vinaigrette.

🐟 “The fish with potato crust was awesome! Kids were happy too. Honestly the best restaurant inside of the Fairmont so far.”
— Mia Svenson, Google Review

🍸 Don’t Miss Happy Hour: Bar & Lounge Menu

Looking for something more casual? The Bar & Lounge menu at Nick’s offers an exceptional Happy Hour daily from 4:30 PM to 6:00 PM (excluding holidays), featuring 25% off select items. It’s the perfect time to sample signature dishes and craft cocktails in a more relaxed setting with upscale service and atmosphere.

🍷 Explore the 2,000-Bottle Wine Display

Wine lovers will be amazed by the glass-enclosed, temperature-controlled wine room, showcasing over 2,000 bottles from around the world. Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or enjoying a casual dinner, the sommelier-curated wine list has a perfect pairing for every dish.

🍷 “Elegant ambiance, top-tier service, and unforgettable dishes—can’t wait to return!”
— Nanea, OpenTable Review

👧 Family Friendly: Nick’s Keiki Menu

Dining with little ones? The Keiki Menu (Kids Menu) includes delicious and approachable options for younger guests—without sacrificing quality. It’s just another way Nick’s makes every guest feel welcome.

👨‍👩‍👧 “Kids were happy!”
— Mia Svenson, Google Review

🥂 Host an Elegant Event at Nick’s Fishmarket

Looking for the perfect venue for a celebration or private dinner? The private event space at Nick’s offers stunning surroundings, tailored menus, and five-star service ideal for weddings, birthdays, and corporate gatherings.

🌟 “Excellent as always. Great place for special occasions. Mahalo Nick’s!”
— Carolyn, OpenTable Review

🍮 Don’t Skip Dessert

Wrap up your evening with a sweet treat worthy of the occasion.

Must-Try Picks:

• Nick’s Crème Brulée – Made with Tahitian vanilla bean and topped with seasonal berries.

• Bananas Foster – A tableside favorite flambéed with Myer’s dark rum.

Strawberries Panzin (for two) – Ulupalakua strawberries flambéed and served with Devonshire cream and chocolate sauce.

A Maui Dining Experience Like No Other

Whether you’re celebrating a milestone, enjoying a date night, or simply indulging in Maui’s best seafood, the Nick’s Fishmarket Maui menu consistently delivers. With elegant ambiance, a 2,000-bottle wine room, kid-friendly options, and glowing reviews from guests, it’s no wonder Nick’s is a standout among Wailea-Makena restaurants.

🌅 “Always a great experience here. The food doesn’t disappoint. The views are amazing!”
— George, OpenTable Review

Explore the menu, drop in for Happy Hour, or reserve your table now to discover why Nick’s Fishmarket Maui is a favorite for locals and visitors alike.