Best Seafood Dishes in Maui: What to Order at Nick’s Fishmarket

When it comes to the best seafood in Maui, Nick’s Fishmarket in Wailea sets the gold standard. Located at the luxurious Fairmont Kea Lani, this celebrated Maui seafood restaurant blends island flavors with upscale coastal cuisine, offering a dining experience that’s as memorable as it is mouthwatering.

Whether you’re a local seafood aficionado or a first-time visitor eager to explore the island’s culinary treasures, here’s your curated guide to the top seafood dishes to order at Nick’s Fishmarket.

Seafood Tower – A Showstopper for Sharing

Perfect for two (or more), the Seafood Tower is a guest favorite for a reason. Stacked high with live Kona lobster, oysters Nick’s style, jumbo shrimp, ahi poke, and more, this chilled platter is both luxurious and refreshing. Served with moutarde and cocktail sauces, it’s ideal for kicking off a special evening with friends or family.

“The food is delicious — the seafood tower was perfect to share — and I’m still thinking about the Greek Maui Wowie salad!” – Eugenia J., Yelp

Fresh Island Catch Piccata – A Taste of Hawaii’s Waters

Rotating based on the day’s freshest catch, this entrée offers a delicious introduction to Hawaii’s local seafood. Sautéed in lemon, butter, and capers, and served with farrotto, broccolini, and tomato purée, it’s a zesty, vibrant dish that perfectly captures the island’s bounty.

Ginger-Soy Marinated Ahi – Flavor with a Kick

A favorite for tuna lovers, the Ginger-Soy Marinated Ahi delivers bold, umami-rich flavor. Served with wasabi whipped potatoes, baby bok choy, and lemongrass au jus, this dish balances earthiness and heat with melt-in-your-mouth texture.

“We enjoyed fresh oysters and escargot to start. Sticking with the seafood theme, we also enjoyed ahi tuna and the spicy Moroccan salmon. Both were delicious.” – Bonnie, OpenTable

Diver Scallop & Shrimp Scampi – A Decadent Duo

This beautifully plated dish combines perfectly seared scallops and shrimp with goat cheese tortellini, peas, and garlic butter, topped with pomegranate and pepitas for a pop of brightness and crunch. It’s a standout among seafood dishes in Wailea and a must-try for those craving something rich yet balanced.

Moroccan Spiced Salmon – Island Flavors Meet Global Spice

The Moroccan Spiced Salmon is a bold, flavorful entrée featuring forbidden rice, sautéed spinach, mushrooms, and a vibrant avocado-papaya relish. With tropical ingredients and warming spices, it’s one of the most distinctive and beloved entrees at Nick’s.

“Nick’s Fishmarket provides a memorable dining experience that combines delicious food with a beautiful atmosphere, perfect for a special evening out in Maui.” – Jeramy J., TripAdvisor

Greek Maui Wowie Salad – Light, Fresh, Flavorful

For a lighter start, try the Greek Maui Wowie Salad — a refreshing medley of Maui onions, tiger prawns, avocado, feta, and tomatoes with a caper vinaigrette. It’s crisp, flavorful, and ideal on warm island evenings.

Don’t Skip Dessert: Sweet Endings Worth Savoring

Cap your evening with the Nick’s Crème Brûlée, Strawberries Panzin for two, or the decadent Chocolate-Macadamia Nut Brownie. Each sweet treat is crafted with island ingredients and pairs perfectly with a dessert wine from the extensive cellar.

Why Seafood Lovers Choose Nick’s

At Nick’s Fishmarket, the commitment to fresh, sustainable seafood and exceptional service shines in every dish. Guests rave about the picturesque setting, ocean breezes, and the attentive team that makes each visit feel like a celebration.

“We had an incredible meal and wonderful service… and got to see the gorgeous Kihei sunset. Loved every minute and hope to be back again!” – Jennifer E., Google

Visit One of Maui’s Best Seafood Restaurants

Nick’s Fishmarket isn’t just dinner — it’s a culinary journey through the islands. Located in the heart of Wailea, this iconic Maui seafood restaurant offers a luxurious, relaxed atmosphere perfect for romantic dinners, group celebrations, or anyone seeking the best seafood Maui has to offer.

Reserve your table today and experience the flavors that make Nick’s Fishmarket a standout among Wailea’s top restaurants.