A Culinary Highlight in Wailea Resorts: Why Nick’s Fishmarket Tops the List

When it comes to Wailea resort restaurants, few dining experiences capture the elegance, flavor, and aloha spirit of Maui like Nick’s Fishmarket Maui. Nestled within the Fairmont Kea Lani Maui resort, Nick’s has become a culinary landmark for visitors seeking fine dining in Wailea, where ocean-fresh seafood, glowing tiki torches, and warm island hospitality create unforgettable evenings.

Perfectly Located Near Wailea’s Top Resorts

Set within the Fairmont Kea Lani Maui, Nick’s Fishmarket is just a short drive or stroll from nearby resorts including the Grand Wailea, Wailea Beach Resort, Four Seasons Resort Maui at Wailea, Ho’olei Villas at Grand Wailea, Wailea Beach Villas and Andaz Maui. Guests love the convenience of enjoying one of the island’s most celebrated restaurants without leaving the resort area.

One diner described it best: “This gem is in the Fairmont, Wailea. Food, service, and ambiance don’t get better. The resort is beautiful, a walk around the grounds after dinner is a must.”

Whether you’re celebrating a special occasion or enjoying your first night in Maui, Nick’s offers a seamless dining experience surrounded by the beauty of Wailea.

Fine Dining in Wailea, Redefined

Nick’s Fishmarket combines the sophistication of fine dining with the relaxed luxury that defines Maui. The open-air garden seating glows under string lights, creating a romantic, resort-style atmosphere that feels both elegant and welcoming.

A recent guest shared, “One of our favorite meals in Wailea. Our waiter, Chris, was excellent and made our first night in Maui so special… a really beautiful atmosphere. Could not have asked for a better dinner experience!”

From attentive service to a polished yet friendly staff, Nick’s captures the elevated hospitality that makes dining in Wailea memorable.

Signature Dishes That Capture Maui’s Flavors

The menu showcases fresh island seafood and premium cuts of meat, prepared with Mediterranean-inspired techniques and locally sourced ingredients. Some guest favorites include:

• Potato Scaled Mahi Mahi with Asparagus, Yukon Gold Mashed Potatoes, Beurre Rouge
• 14 oz Rib Eye Steak with loaded Mashed Potatoes, Grilled Asparagus, Baby Carrots, Garlic Butter 
• Crab Cakes and Potstickers, ideal for sharing
• Seafood Tower with live Kona lobster, oysters Nick’s style, jumbo shrimp, ahi poke, Moutarde & cocktail sauce

Each dish pairs beautifully with a glass from Nick’s award-winning wine list, with over 2,000 fine vintages from all over the world.

One visitor wrote, “By far my favorite restaurant I have eaten at in Maui. The views were impeccable, the food delicious, and the service on point. Drinks were great as well. Highly recommend!”

Relaxed Elegance: Dress Code and Ambiance

Guests describe the setting as “fancy but resort casual,” the perfect blend for Wailea. Dress “Hawaii nice” and you’ll fit right in. After dinner, take a stroll through the Fairmont Kea Lani Maui’s tropical gardens or enjoy a cocktail at the bar, where locals and travelers mingle in laid-back luxury.

Another reviewer shared, “Located in the Fairmont resort, fancy place but okay to dress resort casual. Service is always great, as is the food. Dessert is quite a show!”

Why Nick’s Fishmarket Tops the List of Wailea Resort Restaurants

• Located inside the Fairmont Kea Lani Maui, near all major Wailea resorts
• Known for fresh island seafood and award-winning service
• Features one of Maui’s most extensive wine lists
• Offers romantic open-air dining perfect for couples and celebrations
• Seamless access with complimentary valet and self-parking

As one happy guest summed it up, “We came to Nick’s twice on our trip to Maui… everything we ordered was great. Would recommend!”

Experience the Best of Fine Dining in Wailea

For travelers looking for the best restaurants near Wailea Beach, Nick’s Fishmarket Maui stands out as both a culinary destination and a celebration of island hospitality. Whether it’s your first night on Maui or a special occasion under the stars, Nick’s is where memories and meals shine brightest.

Reserve your table today and experience why guests call Nick’s Fishmarket the culinary highlight of Wailea resort dining.