Wailea Fine Dining at Its Best: Discover Nick’s Fishmarket Maui

When it comes to fine dining on Maui, few restaurants capture the essence of luxury, culinary artistry, and island hospitality like Nick’s Fishmarket. Located in the heart of Wailea-Makena within the Fairmont Kea Lani, Nick’s has earned its reputation as one of the island’s top fine dining destinations—thanks to its award-winning cuisine, romantic ambiance, and impeccable service.

A Prime Location in Wailea-Makena

Nestled among Wailea’s world-class resorts and white-sand beaches, Nick’s Fishmarket offers guests an elevated dining experience with stunning surroundings. The open-air setting allows diners to soak in the warm Hawaiian breeze and dine under the stars, all while surrounded by tropical landscaping and sophisticated décor. Whether you’re arriving from your hotel suite or dressed for a special celebration, the setting at Nick’s is both elegant and inviting.

Award-Winning Cuisine with Island Flair

The heart of Nick’s Fishmarket lies in its menu—an artful blend of fresh Hawaiian seafood, premium cuts of steak, and Mediterranean-inspired flavors. Every dish is crafted with locally sourced ingredients and global culinary techniques, ensuring that each bite is a celebration of Maui’s rich bounty and culinary diversity.

Signature dishes include:

• Fresh Island Catch Piccata – Lightly sautéed with lemon, butter, and capers, served with creamy farrotto and a 24-hour tomato purée.
• Potato Scaled Mahi Mahi – Crispy potato crusted mahi mahi with tender asparagus, Yukon Gold mashed potatoes, and beurre rouge.
• Live Kona Maine Lobster – A true indulgence, prepared to perfection and served with rich butter sauce.
• Filet Mignon – A must-try for steak lovers, featuring tender, prime cuts grilled to your preference.
• Avocado “Mujadra” – Creamy avocado paired with nutty black Thai rice and a crisp vegetable pancake, finished with a warm, tangy mango vinaigrette.
• Nick’s Crème Brûlée – A silky Tahitian vanilla bean custard with a perfectly caramelized top, paired with a Ramos Pinto 20-Year Tawny Port.

An expertly curated wine list rounds out the experience, with selections from both old and new world vineyards. From crisp whites to bold reds, the pairings enhance every course and cater to the most refined palates.

Exceptional Service that Elevates Every Visit

At Nick’s Fishmarket, the commitment to excellence goes beyond the plate. The restaurant is known for its outstanding service, where each guest is welcomed with warmth and treated like a VIP. From tableside preparations to personalized menu recommendations, the staff’s attention to detail turns every visit into a memorable occasion.

Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, an anniversary, or simply indulging in a night out, the Nick’s team ensures your experience is nothing short of extraordinary.

A Romantic Escape in the Heart of Maui

Searching for the perfect place for a romantic dinner in Wailea? Nick’s Fishmarket delivers the ideal atmosphere with candlelit tables, ocean breezes, and an intimate outdoor terrace. It’s a favorite for honeymoons, proposals, and date nights—and offers private dining options for those seeking an even more exclusive experience.

The Perfect Fusion of Luxury and Aloha

Dining at Nick’s is about more than food—it’s about immersing yourself in the luxury and spirit of aloha that defines Wailea. The relaxed island vibe pairs seamlessly with upscale service, offering a balance that’s uniquely Hawaiian.

Whether you’re a longtime local or visiting Maui for the first time, a night at Nick’s is a must.

Plan Your Visit

Ready to experience Wailea fine dining at its finest? Make Nick’s Fishmarket part of your Maui itinerary. Due to high demand—especially during holiday seasons—reservations are strongly recommended.

From fresh seafood and premium steaks to fine wines and flawless service, Nick’s Fishmarket offers an unforgettable dining experience that keeps guests coming back year after year.

Make your next Maui meal one to remember. Reserve your table at Nick’s Fishmarket today and discover why it’s one of the top fine dining restaurants in Wailea.